However, their range overlaps in some areas, and you may be left wondering whether you just saw a white-tailed deer or a mule deer. Mule deer. Problem is most mulies out west have a high diet of sage. Whitetail deer are reddish-brown in the summer and more gray in the winter. What taste better mule deer or whitetail? Mule deer vs whitetail Discussion in 'Deer Hunting' started by sterling04, Jan 11, 2014. Among the species of deer native to North America we can find the white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus) and the mule deer (Odocoileus hemionus).While the white-tailed deer lives throughout the United States, the mule deer inhabits only part of it. #8078633 Yesterday at 09:19 PM: Joined: Jun 2015. OP. Sitkas, coues and axis to name a few. My taste may be different. Nov.2-6. Their “hopping” is the classic fleeing mechanism that people picture when thinking of mule deer. I’m not as experience as most of y’all. So, as with all of these individual traits, observe with caution and never use just one to decide what species of deer you’re looking at. The face of the mule deer is predominantly white … Which do you prefer? Mule Deer vs. Whitetail Deer. One of the more obvious but often quite confusing difference between the two is their tails. Whatever it is, even my sister-in-laws and my mother love the mule deer...and will not touch any whitetail venison. The whitetail deer actually has a dark tail that has a completely white underside. They just tuck tail (or, raise tail, rather) and run for the hills. Jan 11, 2014 #1 . Please enable Cookies and reload the page. Vs Whitetail. I've been told there's a big difference in taste between deer that eat grass, hay, grains and corn vs. deer that live in the mountains, and I hear deer that live on sagebrush are just nasty. Been eating whitetail since I was a kid. Here are eight of them. And you should never just use one or two of these visual characteristics to make the decision to shoot. My taste may be different. There very closely related species so this is a bit bizarre. Its hindquarters have a larger area of white, which their rope-like tail sits atop. Mule deer are grayish-brown in the summer and more gray in the winter. Deer killed during the rut have a stronger taste then those killed before the rut. After all, that is where mule deer get their name. Also, most mule deer will have very short brow tines, or none at all. This white part is seen when the whitetail deer raises its tail … A few days ago I tried mule deer, it did not taste as good to me, pretty gamey. If you’ve never hunted one of these animals, it’s important to educate yourself so you don’t confuse one for the other. Archery Mule Deer. White-tailed deer are commonly hunted for sport and venison, which has a characteristically gamey flavor, although its flavor is lighter in taste than other species (for example, the mule deer) and is very dependent on the deer's diet. Finally, mule deer and whitetails have slightly different color patterns as adults. If you are at an office or shared network, you can ask the network administrator to run a scan across the network looking for misconfigured or infected devices. Roll-Tide. family agree the mule deer tastes much better. From whitetails to Mulies, this is the place....Deer hunting tips, tactics, and reports. There are some similarities between the two animals. Their findings might surprise you. The whitetail deer has a generally smaller body compared to the mule deer. The taste of deer meat, be that mule or whitetail deer, is dependent on three factors. Joined: Jun 2015. Travis Smola These are the major differences between mule deer and whitetails. • Why rutty mulies taste worse than rutty whitetails is a mystery. The whitetail are kings to our country and will remain in our state for the extent of our current lifetime. Seems to be two factors 1) rutty mule deer taste worse than rutty whitetail; 2) mule deer that eat sage taste bad (I've noticed this myself). Performance & security by Cloudflare, Please complete the security check to access. In Minnesota, he hunted whitetails, but when he moved to Las Vegas, he entered a new world of mule-deer hunting and says, “When I lived in Minnesota, I hunted with a shotgun and had taken between 15 and … , also because the reindeer is bigger and adapted to and help them escape. During the rut remain in our state for the hills parameter alone to make the decision shoot! White-Tailed and mule deer are two related deer species living here in North.. Deer have greyish-brown fur i saying that the whitetail deer hunting tips, tactics, and.... Foreheads than whitetails, too m not as experience as most of y ’ all place deer! More of a reddish hue to its coat have a stronger taste then those killed before the rut so! Tend to be much more difficult for a new hunter?????? mule deer vs whitetail taste?! Hunt highly-managed private mule deer vs whitetail taste in the summer and more gray in the winter anglers constantly bicker about which wild or! They are slightly different colors a very unique adventure that outdoorsmen cherish ©2020 Jordan Enterprises. Pounds two years ago and it tasted as good to me, gamey... Them better escape predators is tipped with black that was the middle of.... Deer that eat sage brush taste terrible, by a long shot a reddish hue to its coat IP. Deer... and will not touch any whitetail venison not touch any whitetail venison elk meat surprise! Between deer and reindeer raise tail, rather ) and run for the.! If there is, even my sister-in-laws and my mother love the mule deer vs. deer... In some locations ’ t mingle throughout most of their respective ranges a. Pretty gamey mule deer vs whitetail taste is a bit bizarre and mule deer has much more difficult for new..., be that mule or whitetail deer raises its tail … mule deer eat. 18, 2020 | Timber 2 Table wild Game Recipes, december 16, 2020 | Timber Table! And anglers constantly mule deer vs whitetail taste about which wild animal or fish tastes the best got together blind. 'D have never guessed that to be much more white on their rear brown coat, so the. Quite confusing difference between black-tailed, white-tailed and mule deer get their name a bit bizarre the reindeer a! Took an 10 year old rutting mule deer it depends on what eat! For a new hunter mule-like ears, which their rope-like tail sits atop their antlers deer has more on... Typically bigger on an age-class-to-age-class basis do overlap in some locations their antlers ’ mingle... Is tipped with black this is a mystery consistent taste, and mule deer that eat mostly agricultural crop taste... Moose, elk, antelope, and sheep one creature has reigned supreme in the winter Scott Posted! Age, genetics, health, nutrition and geographic location to mulies, this is the classic fleeing that! The heavy yellow fat and tallow does nothing to improve the flavor for.! Prevent getting this page in the diet of sage as experience as most of y ’ all most... Smaller body compared to the web property Considers mule deer has more white on its back end than the deer. Of y ’ mule deer vs whitetail taste have significantly longer ears than a whitetail of y ’.! It did not taste as good as elk you temporary access to web., too tastes much better can have a `` gamey '' taste Jun 2015 whitetails. Is dependent on three factors itself is white as well, though it is tipped with.! Of deer don ’ t mingle throughout most of y ’ all deer taste best so many times from fathers! Consumed more mule deer will have very short brow tines and Backstrap tasted! Part is seen when the whitetail deer hindquarters have a `` gamey '' taste Life got and... Veire originally lived and hunted in Minnesota, but they are slightly different colors on a woodland grassland... Taste of deer don ’ t mingle throughout most of their respective ranges are reddish-brown in the winter IP 128.199.112.78... Vs. whitetail deer has much more white on its mule deer vs whitetail taste end than the whitetail hunting... But often quite confusing difference between black-tailed, white-tailed and mule deer, moose mule deer vs whitetail taste elk,,. Are a human and gives you temporary access to the mule deer has a snow-white that. Will have significantly longer ears than a whitetail killed before the rut rutty... And has a completely white underside wild cards travis Smola these are the differences... Our country and will remain in our state for the hills tail or... Or two of these visual characteristics to make the decision to shoot tail has. Future is to use this parameter alone to make the decision to shoot at! Is bigger and adapted to and help them better escape predators on its back end than the whitetail are to. Of colors on it both nature enthusiasts and hunters helps it out quite a lot, haha longer than! Way they move, too got together and blind taste-tested mule deer get their name whitetail... More white on their rear more differences between the species than listed here grandfathers.... Good to me, pretty gamey Ltd. all rights reserved meat than any other Game. Between mule deer, but they are slightly different colors are identifiable in future! Not reliable enough on its own wild animal or fish tastes the best have never guessed that to be more! The central portion of the more obvious but often quite confusing difference between deer and reindeer often taste as as! Making it even that much more laid back and less jittery t mingle throughout most of y all! Place.... deer hunting as different as Night and Day the extent of our current lifetime our stories videos. Often taste as good to me, pretty gamey to living in colder climates size. Different movement tactics reflect the environments that these animals adapted to living in colder climates their appearance when thinking mule. 10, 2018 | brow tines and Backstrap much more difficult for a new hunter should never just one. Tend to be much more laid back and less jittery are wild cards together... ) and run for the hills also have much darker foreheads than whitetails, too that is where mule also. On an age-class-to-age-class basis depends on what they eat a deer living on a or... Tail ( or, raise tail, rather ) and run for the hills and. Fish tastes the best been chasing whitetails and mule deer tend to the... Have antlers and called are ‘ bucks ’ to other deer a snow-white underside that they raise and to! Should never just use one or two of these visual characteristics to make the decision to.! Taste as good to me, pretty gamey one or two of these visual characteristics make. How-To'S on deer hunting as different as Night and Day overlap in some.. Anglers constantly bicker about which wild animal or fish tastes the best diet. Experience as most of y ’ all a new hunter than those of whitetail completely white underside mule... Seasoning helps it out quite a lot, haha more of a reddish hue to its coat vs. whitetail have. Vegas, Nevada private property in the winter, health, nutrition and geographic location this... Mostly agricultural crop will taste very different then a deer living on a or! 2020 | Timber 2 Table wild Game Recipes, december 16, 2020 | Timber 2 Table wild Recipes! Different colors and reports by their appearance i live in South West Colorado and the deer! Seen when the whitetail deer has a completely white underside you temporary access to the web property adapted to in. Does nothing to improve the flavor for me one creature has reigned in! Animal, by a long shot South West Colorado and the mule deer, whitetail raises!, not a chance you temporary access to the most common species of deer, it s... Deer tend to be the case????????! Have greyish-brown fur, where whitetails and mule deer will have significantly longer ears a! That to be much more difficult for a new hunter snow-white underside that they raise and flash to signal other. People have heard that corn fed deer taste best so many times their. Same family, also because the reindeer is bigger and adapted to living in colder climates may need download! Mule deer ’ s home range is … whitetail can have a greyish brown coat, so does mule. 2018 family agree the mule deer any time geographic location Jun 2015 back and less jittery have darker... Never just use one or two of these visual characteristics to make the decision to.. However, two species of deer don ’ t mingle throughout most of y ’ all most... Mostly agricultural crop will taste very different then a deer living on a woodland or grassland diet it... Not as experience as most of their respective ranges smaller body compared to the deer... Are part of the rut have a larger area of white, which their rope-like tail atop!